Severe genu recurvatum and total knee arthroplasty: how can instability be prevented?
Background: Genu recurvatum is an uncommon but technically demanding finding in candidates for total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Severe recurvatum, defined as hyperextension greater than 10°, affects fewer than 1% of these patients, although its prevalence may be underestimated. The deformity carries a considerable risk of postoperative instability, yet the literature remains sparse. This review analyses the available evidence and proposes a practical strategy for preventing secondary instability after TKA, particularly in severe recurvatum. Methods: The aetiology and biomechanics of genu recurvatum were described. Published series of TKA in knees with preoperative recurvatum were then reviewed for outcomes, risk factors for failure and indications for constrained implants. Expert recommendations were then formulated.
Results: Five retrospective series were identified. They included 10 to 57 knees each, with a mean preoperative recurvatum of 8° to 11° and a mean follow-up of 2 to 7.4 years. All reported good clinical and radiological results with cruciate-retaining or posterior-stabilised implants. In controlled series, survivorship and functional scores were comparable with those of knees without recurvatum, and prosthetic design did not appear to influence outcome. A reduced distal femoral resection could alter joint-line and patellar height, without apparent clinical consequence. When instability occurred, it was mainly associated with concomitant medial laxity. An unrecognised neurological cause with quadriceps deficiency was a further source of failure. A hinged prosthesis is indicated in poliomyelitis or paralytic conditions, in cases of uncertain coronal balance or major deformity, or when full extension without recurvatum cannot be achieved intraoperatively.
Conclusions: Genu recurvatum is not in itself an indication for a constrained implant. Preoperative assessment should establish the aetiology, test the quadriceps and analyse gait, since paralytic recurvatum must be partly preserved. Intraoperatively, the deformity should be corrected through bone cuts and implants rather than soft-tissue procedures, aiming for full extension without recurvatum. This relies on a tibia-first cut with step-by-step gap assessment, a reduced distal femoral resection and, if required, a thicker insert. Ten golden rules and a decision-making algorithm are proposed to guide arthroplasty surgeons. Prevention of instability depends more on surgical strategy than on implant choice, but a hinged implant should be available in theatre.