Personalised alignment and prosthetic kinematics: two inseparable concepts in total knee arthroplasty
Total knee arthroplasty (TKA) performed according to the principles of mechanical alignment achieves implant survival rates frequently exceeding 90% at 15 years, yet close to 20% of patients remain partially dissatisfied. This gap between objective results and how patients perceive them has driven two parallel developments. The first is personalised alignment strategies that seek to restore each patient’s pre-arthritic anatomy. The second is medial pivot implants designed to reproduce the asymmetrical kinematics of the native knee. Although both pursue the same objective, the literature has so far examined them largely in isolation. This narrative review analyses the relationship between the various kinematic alignment concepts and medial pivot implant design. It first outlines the principles and limitations of mechanical alignment, whose systematic correction of constitutional deformity may alter joint line obliquity, ligament tension and native kinematics. It then describes complete (unrestricted) kinematic alignment and its principal variants: restricted kinematic alignment, which applies safe limits to limb alignment and component orientation; functional alignment, which uses dynamic ligament assessment to obtain balanced gaps throughout the range of movement; and patellofemoral-tuned kinematic alignment, which incorporates trochlear reconstruction through three-dimensional planning. The kinematics of the native knee, with a stable medial pivot and a mobile lateral compartment, are then reviewed as the biomechanical basis of medial pivot implants. The available evidence suggests that neither alignment strategy nor implant design alone restores physiological biomechanics. Medial pivot implants positioned in mechanical alignment only partially reproduce native kinematics. A posterior-stabilised implant placed in restricted kinematic alignment has been associated with an increased risk of aseptic tibial loosening.
Conversely, medial pivot implants combined with unrestricted kinematic alignment have yielded better function and a more natural-feeling knee than ultracongruent implants at five years. Taken together, alignment strategy and implant design appear to be inseparable components of a single reconstructive strategy. For orthopaedic surgeons, the choice of implant should therefore follow from the alignment concept and ligament targets selected. Future research should move beyond isolated comparisons to evaluate specific alignment–implant pairings tailored to each patient’s anatomical, ligamentous and functional characteristics.