Carl Hueter and the anterior approach to the hip from historical origins to contemporary renaissance

Summary

The direct anterior approach to the hip has undergone remarkable worldwide expansion in joint replacement surgery over the past two decades, and is frequently presented as a modern innovation. In reality, it is one of the oldest approaches to the hip, its anatomical foundations having been laid in 1883 by the German surgeon Carl Hueter (1838–1882). This historical review seeks to restore Hueter to his rightful place in the development of orthopaedic surgery, to trace the lineage of the approach to the present day, and to set out the contemporary evidence that justifies continuing interest in it.

Trained in Bernhard von Langenbeck’s Berlin school and later professor at Greifswald, Hueter described the approach in his Grundriss der Chirurgie not for arthroplasty but for resection of the femoral head in suppurative tuberculous coxitis. His technique exploited a strictly intermuscular and internervous plane — subsequently termed the ‘Hueter interval’ — between the sartorius anteriorly and the tensor fasciae latae posteriorly, sacrificing no muscle insertion. The very advantages promoted today, namely muscle preservation, a low dislocation rate and rapid recovery, were all identified in his original description.

Hueter’s premature death at the age of 43 interrupted the direct transmission of his technique, which lay largely dormant until it was redescribed by Smith-Petersen, applied to arthroplasty by Robert and Jean Judet in Paris from 1947, miniaturised by Siguier in 1993, and disseminated worldwide by Matta in the 2000s. Contemporary series confirm a low dislocation rate, superior early functional scores and shorter hospital stay, offset by a substantial learning curve of approximately 100 procedures. Alongside the eponymous Hueter–Volkmann law of growth-plate biomechanics, the anterior approach constitutes Hueter’s enduring legacy. The authors argue that the common designation ‘Smith-Petersen approach’ perpetuates a historical error, and that fairness and accuracy require the orthopaedic literature to restore the name of the Hueter approach.

Subscription or login is required to view the full text.

Please Login or Register!